ACA Survives Latest Supreme Court Challenge

The Supreme Court released its opinion today in a highly anticipated third challenge to President Obama’s signature health care law, the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (“ACA”).

The 7-2 majority opinion, authored by Justice Breyer, decided Texas v. California on procedural grounds, holding that because the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 set the individual mandate penalty at $0, the plaintiffs were unable to establish harm.

Justice Thomas filed a concurring opinion that would also have decided the case on a lack of standing grounds. Justices Alito and Gorsuch would have endorsed a novel theory of standing through inseverability. In short, the dissenting opinion would have found that a case or controversy existed because plaintiffs were harmed by certain provisions of the ACA that were inseverable from an unlawful provision—even though they were not harmed by the actual provision that they argued was unlawful. However, the majority opined that severability analysis (in which the Court determines whether Congress would have intended that certain closely-related provisions stand or fall together when the constitutionality of only one is at issue) should not be considered until after a provision has already been determined to be unlawful, and thus could not factor into the initial question of whether plaintiffs have standing to bring a lawsuit.  

The Supreme Court had previously upheld the bulk of the ACA in two prior lawsuits, National Federation of Independent Business v. Sibelius, in 2012, and King v. Burwell, in 2015.

 

Latest Thinking

View more Insights
Insights Center
close
Loading...
Knowledge assets are defined in the study as confidential information critical to the development, performance and marketing of a company’s core business, other than personal information that would trigger notice requirements under law. For example,
The new study shows dramatic increases in threats and awareness of threats to these “crown jewels,” as well as dramatic improvements in addressing those threats by the highest performing organizations. Awareness of the risk to knowledge assets increased as more respondents acknowledged that their